- Rich Incognito suspended The Dolphins have now suspended Incognito indefinitely
- Fins keep season alive Cam Wake's sack/safety in OT preserves the Fins victory and season
- Fins lose control in 2nd half Dolphins lose a 14 point lead and the game to the Patriots
- Fins trade for OT McKinnie Miami sends a late round conditional pick for OT Bryant McKinnie
Brian Catanzaro’s Top 10 Fins Board Part I
There are 3 rules for reading this board:
–Eliminate these 7 players from discussion who have little-to-no chance of being available at #12: QB Geno Smith, OT Luke Joeckel, OT Eric Fisher, DT Sharrif Floyd, DT Star Lotulelei, CB Dee Milliner.
–This is MY board for the #12 pick, not Jeff Ireland’s.
–Criticism is welcomed as long as it doesn’t begin with “We don’t need a ….” comment. I subscribe to the Giants/Ravens/Packers/Patriots draft philosophy of taking the best available player while using need as a tie-breaker. There is no reason to read on if you’re uncomfortable with that.
Here are picks 6-10
10) G Jonathan Cooper, North Carolina (6-2, 311)
Closest NFL Comparison: Wade Smith (Dolphins)
Dolfans would storm Dolphins HQ’s with torches and pitchforks if Jonathan Cooper were selected with the #12 pick. Me? I could stomach it. Cooper is a plug-and-play OG perfectly suited for Philbin and Sherman’s ZBS. He combines TE-like athleticism with the size and strength (35 bench reps). Cooper teams with C Mike Pouncey to give the Dolphins two Pro Bowl players. Comparisons to former HOF LG Randall McDaniel are extremely accurate given Cooper’scombination of balance, strength, and intellegence. Don’t laugh at the comparison – Wade Smith has become a Pro Bowl player at LG for the Texans in Gary Kubiak’s zone blocking scheme.
9) CB Xavier Rhodes, Florida St* (6-2, 217)
Closest NFL Comparison: Aqib Talib (Patriots)
Rhodes is the consensus #12 pick in mock drafts because he immediately replaces Sean Smith’s ability to match up with bigger WR’s in the redzone. Still, he’s not my pick at #12 for 3 reasons: too-big frame, hips, and CB depth in the 2nd and 3rd rounds. He lacks the polish of a dominant boundary CB with additional questions about running with smaller WR’s in the Danny Amendola/Santonio Holmes mold here in the AFC East. It would make more sense to draft one of the eight players listed above while waiting for a CB in the 2nd round because it a very deep class.
8) DE Barkevious Mingo, LSU* (6-4, 241)
Closest NFL Comparison: Michael Johnson (Bengals)
Mingo is a quick-twitch edge rusher with freakish athletic ability. He’s a raw player who underachived last season at LSU with only 4.5 sacks, but could be one NFL coach away from being another Jevon Kearse. He lacked effort in his Junior season, and often looked like a sloppy football player who didn’t quite “get it”. Mingo and Wake on 3rd down would be terrorizing for opposing QB’s. Even if Mingo struggles to adapt to the LDE spot after playing RDE at LSU, he could succeed Cameron Wake, who turns 32 at the end of the 2013 season.
7) DE Ezeikel Ansah, BYU (6-5, 271)
Closest NFL Comparison: Carlos Dunlap (Bengals)
Buyer beware. Ansah is the biggest mystery in the Top-15. He has a great size-speed combo (4.63/40 at 271 pounds) but only had 10 tackles in two season at BYU before a mini break-out season in 2012 (4.5 sacks, 1 FF). He could be the best athlete available at #12.
6) DE Tank Carradine, Florida St* (6-4, 276)
Closest NFL Comparison: Cameron Jordan (Saints)
“Tank” was on his way to being a Top-10 pick before tearing an ACL in late November vs. Florida. His workout on April 20th will mean everything. He’s a big, powerful DE who terrorized opposing LT’s for 11 sacks and 13 tackles-for-loss in his final 12 games with the ‘Noles before tearing his ACL. Extremely powerful RDE (32 bench reps) who plays with a wide base and great speed for his size.
Join us on our message board and share your thoughts at FinNation Forums
Join us on Twitter at @FinNation